Background Interleukin-15 (IL-15) is an important cytokine necessary for proliferation and maintenance of natural killer (NK) and CD8+ T cells, and with great promise as an immuno-oncology therapeutic. However, IL-15 has a very short half-life and a single administration does not provide the sustained exposure required for optimal stimulation of target immune cells. The purpose of this work was to develop a very long-acting prodrug that would maintain IL-15 within a narrow therapeutic window for long periods—similar to a continuous infusion.
Methods We prepared and characterized hydrogel microspheres (MS) covalently attached to IL-15 (MS~IL-15) by a releasable linker. The pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of MS~IL-15 were determined in C57BL/6J mice. The antitumor activity of MS~IL-15 as a single agent, and in combination with a suitable therapeutic antibody, was tested in a CD8+ T cell-driven bilateral transgenic adenocarcinoma mouse prostate (TRAMP)-C2 model of prostatic cancer and a NK cell-driven mouse xenograft model of human ATL (MET-1) murine model of adult T-cell leukemia.
Results On subcutaneous administration to mice, the cytokine released from the depot maintained a long half-life of about 168 hours over the first 5 days, followed by an abrupt decrease to about ~30 hours in accordance with the development of a cytokine sink. A single injection of MS~IL-15 caused remarkably prolonged expansions of NK and ɣδ T cells for 2 weeks, and CD44hiCD8+ T cells for 4 weeks. In the NK cell-driven MET-1 murine model of adult T-cell leukemia, single-agent MS~IL-1550 μg or anti-CCR4 provided modest increases in survival, but a combination—through antibody-depedent cellular cytotoxicity (ADCC)—significantly extended survival. In a CD8+ T cell-driven bilateral TRAMP-C2 model of prostatic cancer, single agent subcutaneous MS~IL-15 or unilateral intratumoral agonistic anti-CD40 showed modest growth inhibition, but the combination exhibited potent, prolonged bilateral antitumor activity.
Conclusions Our results show MS~IL-15 provides a very long-acting IL-15 with low Cmax that elicits prolonged expansion of target immune cells and high anticancer activity, especially when administered in combination with a suitable immuno-oncology agent.
- translational medical research
- natural killer cells
Data availability statement
All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.
Interleukin-15 (IL-15) is a ~14 kDa protein belonging to a family of interleukins that use a common cytokine-receptor γ-chain. IL-15 is essential for the proliferation, maintenance, and survival of natural killer (NK) and CD8+ T cells, and recombinant human IL-15 (rhIL-15, hereafter referred to as IL-15) is of major interest as an immuno-oncology agent.1–5 This pleiotropic cytokine stimulates immune cell responses through the same dimeric IL-2Rβ/γc receptor complex as IL-2 (figure 1) but the two cytokines exhibit functionally distinct activities associated with their unique Rα subunits.6 IL-15 is expressed in association with its high-affinity IL-15Rα receptor chain on the surface of monocytes and dendritic cells and is predominately trans-presented to target immune cells to form a high-affinity IL-15/IL-15Rα/IL-2Rβ/γc complex7 8; in addition, to a lesser extent free soluble IL-15 can act in cis on dimeric and trimeric receptors. IL-2 binds with moderate affinity to the same IL-2Rβ/γc receptor complex and with high affinity to the IL-2Rα/IL-2Rβ/γc trimeric receptor found on regulatory T cells. Thus, both IL-15 and IL-2 bind to and stimulate NK and CD8+ T cells, but regulatory T cells are predominately stimulated by IL-2. Moreover, in contrast to IL-2, IL-15 inhibits activation-induced cells death, which leads to memory cell survival.9 Although IL-15 has modest anticancer activity as a single agent, it shows significant effects in combination with other immuno-oncology agents and it is in this setting that IL-15 is expected to be efficacious.3
NK and memory T-cell proliferation requires IL-15 exposure at a level above a threshold concentration for a protracted period—a critical ‘time-over-target’.10–12 However, IL-15 has a short t1/2—only ~2.5 hours in humans—and the high dose of a single injection necessary to achieve adequate sustained exposure is accompanied by a high Cmax and associated toxicities.13 Hence, extensive efforts have been expended to develop potent, long-acting IL-15 receptor agonists in which a single dose maintains the agonist in a narrow therapeutic window for a long period. The most common approaches employed to increase the t1/2 of IL-15 involves increasing the molecular size to reduce the renal elimination rate and/or by targeting the neonatal Fc receptor (FcRn). These include incorporation of part of the IL-15Rα and/or attachment to polyethylene glycol (PEG), Fc, or serum albumin to the cytokine, and are exemplified by Alt-803 (IL-15 N72D/IL-15Rα-Fc), hetIL-15 (IL-15/IL-15Rα), RLI (single chain fusion of IL-15 and IL-15Rαsushi), and NKTR-255 (PEGylated IL-15).14 Enigmatically, although the half-life extension technologies used often lengthen the t1/2 of a protein to a week or longer in humans, the IL-15 agonists studied have systemic elimination t1/2s of not longer than 1 day and usually only several hours.14 Another approach to maintain a constant level of IL-15 for a prolonged period is continuous intravenous infusion (CIV). Here, 5-day15 or 10-day16 CIV of IL-15 showed remarkable increases of CD8+ T cells, NK cells, and CD56brightNK cells. Regardless, CIV administration is an impractical route of administration, and it is desirable to have an effective IL-15 agonist possessing the convenience and acceptance of a single subcutaneous injection of once weekly or longer intervals.
We have developed a general approach for half-life extension of therapeutics in which the pharmacokinetics (PK) of the circulating drug can mimic a continuous infusion. As previously described,17 18 a drug is covalently tethered to a long-lived carrier by a linker that slowly cleaves by β-elimination to release the free drug (figure 2). The base-catalyzed first-order cleavage rate of the linker is controlled by the nature of an electron-withdrawing ‘modulator’ (Mod), which regulates the acidity of an adjacent carbon-hydrogen bond. These linkers are not affected by enzymes and are extraordinarily stable when stored at low pH and temperature.17 19 One carrier we use is a mesoporous tetra-PEG hydrogel.18 20 These hydrogels—fabricated as uniform ~60 µm microspheres (MS)20—are injected subcutaneously through a small-bore needle where they serve as a stationary, localized depot to slowly release the drug to the systemic circulation. We also incorporate slower cleaving β-eliminative linkers in crosslinks of these polymers, so gel degradation occurs in vivo after drug release.18 21
The primary objective of this work was to develop a very long-acting IL-15. First, we describe the synthesis and characterization of an MS~IL-15 prodrug. Next, we describe the PK of the conjugate in mice, and show a very long half-life and low Cmax of the released cytokine. Then, we describe the remarkably long-lasting effects of subcutaneous MS~IL-15 on the proliferation and expansion of NK and CD8+ T cells. Finally, we demonstrate potent antitumor activity of MS~IL-15 in combination with anti-CCR4 in the MET-1 model of adult T-cell leukemia (ATL), and in combination with intratumoral (IT) agonistic anti-CD40 in the bilateral TRAMP-C2 model of prostatic cancer.
Materials and methods
The following are materials and methods used in this work. Complete details of chemical syntheses and characterization, PK and pharmacodynamic (PD) experiments, and therapeutic studies are provided in online supplemental information.
IL-15 (>95% pure) was provided by the National Cancer Institute. Receptor-linked interleukin-15 (RLI) was produced at ATUM (Newark, California) as reported.22 Mogamulizumab-kpkc (NDC code 42747-761-01) was obtained from the NIH Pharmacy. Anti-CD40 (#BP0016-2) was obtained from BioXCell (Lebanon, New Hampshire). C57B/6J plasma was purchased from Innovative Research (Novi, Michigan). All other chemicals and reagents were purchased from commercial vendors unless otherwise stated.
Preparation of MS~IL-15
As described,23 azido-linker-IL-15 was prepared by conjugating N3-PEG4-Linker(MeSO2)-CHO to the IL-15 via reductive alkylation using NaCNBH3. Excess reagents were removed using a PD-10 column (GE Healthcare). Then, the azido-linker-IL-15 was attached to BCN-derivatized MS through strain promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition. The unreacted BCN groups were capped with N3-PEG7 (Sigma-Aldrich). The MS~IL-15 slurry was washed and equilibrated with 25 mM citrate, pH 6.0, 500 mM NaCl, and 0.05% tween-20 containing 30 mM Met as an anti-oxidant and stored at 4°C.
In vitro characterization of MS~IL-15
The release kinetics of MS~IL-15 were determined under accelerated release conditions as previously described.18 20 The purity of IL-15 on the MS was determined by monitoring the released proteins at pH 9.4, 37°C using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The bioactivity of αN-aminopropyl-IL-15 (IL-15AP) was assessed using the U2OS cell-based assay kit for IL-2Rβγ binding (DiscoverX, Part #93-0998E3CP5).
Pharmacokinetics of MS~IL-15 in immunocompetent mice
Dosing solutions were prepared by diluting the MS~IL-15 slurry in 25 mM Na citrate buffer pH 6.0 containing 500 mM NaCl, 0.05% tween-20, and 1.25% (w/v) hyaluronic acid. Syringes with fixed needles (27 G) were backfilled with the MS~IL-15 conjugate (50 µg IL-15, 100 µL). The contents of the syringes were administered subcutaneously to normal, male C57BL/6J mice or NOD scid gamma (NSG) mice. Blood samples were collected in EDTA collection tubes, containing HALT protease inhibitor, over a predefined time course from alternating groups of mice (n=3/group). Plasma was prepared and stored at –80°C until analysis. The rhIL-15 concentrations in serum were assessed using a hIL-15-specific ELISA (R&D Systems, hIL-15 Quantikine) performed according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Pharmacodynamics of MS~IL15
Normal, male C57BL/6J mice (n=3–5/group) received either a single injection of MS~IL-1550 µg subcutaneously or one to five injections of rhIL-15 (5–50 µg) intraperitoneally. On days 2, 5, 7, 14, 21, and 28, mice were bled or sacrificed. Blood, splenocytes, and lymph node lymphocytes were immunophenotyped to quantitate NK cells, B cells, CD4+, CD8+, CD44hiCD8+, γδ T cells, and Ki67+ cells. Untreated mice were used to determine baseline cell numbers.
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) were prepared using ammonium-chloride-potassium (ACK) lysis buffer and incubated with a fixable viability dye to label dead cells. The FcRγII/II receptor was then blocked using CD16/32 (2.4G2) (BD Biosciences). PBMCs were surface stained using optimal Ab concentrations and fixed for intracellular staining following protocols from the eBioscience Foxp3/Transcription Factor Staining Buffer Set (online supplemental table S1). Stained single cell suspensions were analyzed on either FACScan (BD Biosciences) or Attune NxT flow cytometer (Thermofisher) and data were analyzed using FlowJo cytometry analysis software (TreeStar, Ashland, Oregon).
The TRAMP-C2 cell line, derived from a prostate tumor of the TRAMP mouse, was administered to four groups of wild-type C57BL/6J mice on both flanks. Following reported methods24 when the tumors volumes reached 40–60 mm3, treatment began. Mice were treated with either empty MS, anti-CD40, MS~IL1550 μg, or the combination of MS~IL-1550 μg and anti-CD40. Measurements of the right and left tumors were obtained from caliper measurements. Kaplan-Meier mouse survival plots were generated based on the mouse survival, monitored based on humane end point criteria.
MET-1 murine model of ATL
The MET-1 cell line was established from the peripheral blood collected from a patient with acute ATL.25 The ATL leukemia model MET-1 was established by the intraperitoneal injection of 2×107 MET-1 cells into severe combined immunodeficient/non-obese diabetic (SCID/NOD) wild-type mice as described previously.25 26 Treatment began when the sIL-2Ra levels were >1000 pg/mL serum. MS~IL-1550 µg was administered to mice subcutaneously. On day 10, sIL-2Rα levels were quantitated using a human CD25/IL-2Rα Quantikine ELISA kit (R&D Systems, DR2A00) following manufacturer’s instructions. Kaplan-Meier mouse survival plots were generated based on the survival of mice in each group.
Statistical testing was performed using GraphPad Prism V.9. Values are presented as mean±SD, unless otherwise stated, and are reported in the text and figure legends. In all cases, values of p<0.05 were regarded as statistically significant.
Preparation and characterization of MS~IL-15
We prepared the MS~IL-15 conjugates by a reported method for site-specific attachment of macromolecular carriers to the N-terminus of proteins23 (figure 3). Amine-derivatized MS, prepared from 4-arm PEG20 kDa prepolymers and containing a β-eliminative linker in all crosslinks for programmed biodegradation,20 served as the macromolecular carrier. First, we determined the optimal ratio of N3-linker-aldehyde 4 (Mod MeSO2−) to rhIL-15 that gave the highest balanced yield of monoalkylated N3-linker-IL-15, 5 (online supplemental figure S1). A PEG-shift sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis assay of the optimized reaction mixture23 showed ~45% unreacted IL-15, ~55% IL-15 having one linker and ≤5% with more than one linker; thus, ≥90% of the product was the desired monoalkylated IL-15. Then, the N3-linker-IL-15, 5, was coupled to BCN-modified MS by strain-promoted alkyne-azide cycloaddition, and unreacted 5 and free IL-15 were washed from the particulate MS to give the MS~IL-15 containing ~5 mg IL-15/mL gel slurry.
Base catalyzed β-elimination of the MS~IL-15 resulted in complete release of Nα-amino-propyl IL-15 (IL-15AP) with t1/2 1030 hours, in agreement with previous results using the same linker.23 The purity of IL-15AP on the MS~IL-15 conjugate was assessed by HPLC quantitation of released proteins versus time at pH 9.4; when extrapolated to t=0, ≥95% of the protein on MS analyzed as IL-15AP (online supplemental figure S2). In accordance with the high stability of linkers at low pH and temperature,17 19 after 1 month of storage at pH 6.0, 4°C, the purity of IL-15 on the MS remained >92% (online supplemental figure S2B). Finally, the half maximal effective concentration (EC50) of IL-15AP released from the MS~IL-15 at pH 7.4 over 10 days was the same (95% CI) as native IL-15 in both an IL-2Rβ/γc dimerization cell-based assay and CTLL-2 cell proliferation assay, demonstrating that IL-15AP released from MS is equipotent to native IL-15 (online supplemental figure S3).
Stability of IL-15
Successful use of MS~IL-15 requires that the attached IL-15 be stable in the subcutaneous space and under storage conditions. Asn77 of IL-15 undergoes deamidation with a t1/2 of ~4 days at pH 7.4, 37°C, but the IL-15(Asp77) product is equipotent in the CTLL-2 bioassay and <5% additional degradation occurred over 8 days.27 28 Here, when IL-15 was kept at pH 7.4, 37°C, for 10 days, there was no significant change in EC50 in cell-based IL-2Rβ/γc dimerization or ELISA assays (online supplemental figure S4). At storage conditions at pH 6.0, 4°C, Asn77 deamidation is very slow27 and we observed no significant change in the EC50 of IL-15 over 28 days using the cell-based assay (online supplemental figure S5). Hence, the IL-15 of MS~IL-15 is sufficiently stable to withstand conditions expected in the subcutaneous space and for long-term storage.
Pharmacokinetics of MS~IL-15
The concentration versus time plot of IL-15AP released from a single subcutaneous dose of MS containing 50 µg IL-15, designated as MS~IL-1550 µg, in C57BL/6J mice is shown in figure 4. We chose a standard dose of MS~IL-1550 µg because it provides a plasma concentration in mice similar to the ~200 to 300 pM effective plasma level attained in CIV IL-15 in monkeys29 and man.16 As shown, IL-15AP released from MS~IL-1550 µg eliminates with a t1/2 of ~168 hours over ~120 hours which then abruptly decreases to a t1/2 ~30 hours, both significantly longer than other IL-15 agonists (table 1). When a second dose of MS~IL-1550 µg was administered on day 10 to mice previously treated with MS~IL-1550 µg, the t1/2 was the ~30 hours observed in the second phase (online supplemental figure S6A). Using the area under the curve (AUC)∞ of IL-15AP released from of MS~IL-1550 µg determined from C versus t plots (n=6), the reported clearance (CL) of 49 mL/hour for IL-1530 and the eq. F=AUC∞·CL/dose, we calculated a bioavailability of 66%±12%. With the NSG mouse—deficient in the ɣc receptor and mature immune cells—the C versus t plot after a single dose of MS~IL-1550 µg showed a single t1/2 of 200 hours over 24 days (online supplemental figure S6B). Hence, the unusual biphasic PK in normal mice is likely due to one or more classes of immune cells that are deficient in the NSG mouse.
Potential causes of the biphasic PK are (a) the formation of antidrug antibodies (ADAs) and/or (b) an IL-15-induced ‘cytokine sink’ that increases with target immune cell proliferation and results in increased consumption/CL of IL-15.14 16 31 We considered ADAs improbable since identical biphasic C versus t plots were observed in each of ~40 mice examined over the course of this work; such uniform occurrence and timing of ADA production is not an expected phenomenon. We also tested for the presence of ADAs using a bridging ELISA13 (online supplemental figure S7). Mice were injected with MS~IL-1550 µg and plasma was analyzed at day 10 (n=12); then, after a second injection of MS~IL-1550 µg at day 10 plasma was analyzed at day 17 (n=12). Both time points were sampled during the rapid CL phase when IL-15 was at a non-interfering ~10 pM, so if ADAs contributed to CL, they should be present and detectable. All assayed samples were below the detectable level of ~1.3 nM of the control monoclonal antibody (mAb. Hence, it appears likely that the rapid CL phase is due to a cytokine sink that increases with proliferation of IL-15 target immune cells14; enigmatically, once formed at day 6, the putative sink appears to be stable to at least day 17.
Pharmacodynamic effects of MS~IL-1550 µg and dose equivalent 5 μg IL-15 once a day×5
With few exceptions,32 IL-15 PD effects on immune cell expansion in mice have been quantified by single measurements a short time after administration. While single measurements may suffice for agonists with short half-lives, they do not capture the duration or extent of response elicited by multiple administrations or an agonist with a long half-life. Also, they can be misleading when used to compare effects of different regimens or agonists in cell subtypes that reach maxima at different times. Therefore, initial experiments determined a time course for sampling and demonstrated that empty MS have no significant effect on immune cell expansion over 21-day period (online supplemental figure S8). Figure 5 shows NK and CD8+ T cells in spleen, lymph nodes, and PBMCs monitored over a 28-day period after a single injection of MS~IL-1550 µg and 5 μg IL-15 once a day×5 in mice, and complete results are provided in online supplemental figure S9A,B. We estimated the amount of IL-15AP released from MS~IL-15 each day by the eq. d(n)=D×rn−1(1−r), where D is the initial amount of IL-15 in the depot and r=−(24 hours)×ln2/t1/2. In the present case, after injection of MS~IL-1550 µg using a release t1/2 of 168 hours, the calculated IL-15AP released over day 1 is 4.7 µg, and on day 5 is 3.2 µg, giving an average IL-15AP released over 5 days of ~4 µg/day.
For analyses of PD effects from cell number versus time plots (figure 5), a horizontal line was created from the pretreatment control value extending to the end of the 28-day study period. The duration of expansion was estimated as the closest measured time point to which the experimental data intersected the control horizontal line. The extent of cell expansion was estimated as the AUC over 28 days (AUC28 d) between the horizontal control and the experimental line. Table 2 tabulates the values for duration and AUC28 d from figure 5 and online supplemental figure S9A. When preferred, the fold increase of cell expansion can be estimated as the experimental AUC28 d/control AUC28 d over the time of interest.
Several features of the AUC approach to measure total cell expansion are worthy of note. First, the proliferation AUC28 d values are deceptively lower than conventionally reported because the AUC28 d of parental cells includes the entire contraction phase; over the period of proliferation, the per cent Ki67+ of NK and CD44hiCD8+ T cells were 70%–90% of the parent (online supplemental figure S9A). Second, AUC28 d of long-lived subsets, such as CD44hiCD8+ T cells, may be deceptively high because the contraction phase may be longer than that of the parent. Third, with exception of NK cells, the AUC28 d of target immune cell proliferation and expansion in PBMCs correlated with those from spleen and lymph nodes with R=99.3% and 98.8%, respectively. AUC28 d of NK cells in PBMCs were ~10-fold higher than expected compared with spleen and lymph nodes, which reduced the correlation; interestingly, NTKR-255 also shows very high expansion of NK cells in peripheral blood.32 Therefore, T cell expansion in mouse PBMCs can be legitimately used as surrogates to avoid sacrificing mice and performing numerous surgical procedures.
The duration of immune cell expansion of 5 µg IL-15 once a day×5 vs MS~IL-1550 µg in spleen, lymph nodes, and PBMCs are all quite similar, showing ~14 days for NK, CD8+, and ɣδ T cells, and ~28 days for CD44hiCD8+ T cells. As measured by Ki67+, proliferation of NK, CD8+, and CD44hiCD8+ T cells in all tissues usually peaks at ~2 days then drops to control by 7 days, although proliferation of ɣδ T cells reaches control levels at 14 days (online supplemental figure S9A). As expected, proliferation of CD44lowCD8+-naïve T cells, B cells, and CD4+ T cells were not significant. On average, the AUC28 d of immune cell proliferation and expansion for MS~IL-1550 µg is ~150% of that for 5 µg IL-15once a day×5.
Frutoso et al33 observed hyporesponsiveness of NK cells but not CD8+ T cells after a second injection of IL-15, RLI, or RLI-Fc. On a second injection of MS~IL-1550 µg 28 days after the first, we also observed low (40%) proliferation of NK cells. CD8+ T cells were not affected when measured at a single time 2 days postadministration as reported,33 but the AUC28 d of CD8+ T cells was attenuated by about 50%.
PD effects of single and sequential doses of IL-15 and super-agonist RLI
We determined the PD effects in PBMCs after single doses of 5–50 µg IL-15 (figure 6 and online supplemental figure S10). As shown in figure 6A, incremental doses of IL-15 caused incremental proliferation and expansion of target effector cells, but never to the extent of MS~IL-1550 µg. The 25 µg dose of IL-15 is dose-equivalent to the IL-15AP released from MS~IL-1550 µg over 1 week, and the 50 µg supra-high dose is equivalent to the total amount of IL-15 on MS~IL-1550 µg. In all cases, the PD responses of the single doses examined are much lower than the long-acting MS~IL-1550 µg.
The magnitude of the PD effect by an IL-15 agonist depends on a sufficient level of target engagement for a sufficient period of time,10–12 and wasted cytokine excess over receptor saturation increases Cmax but not signal intensity. As dose is increased, Cmax increases linearly whereas the time during which receptors are effectively saturated increases logarithmically (online supplemental section XII). Figure 6A, inset, shows that AUC28 d of proliferation and expansion of immune cells versus IL-15 concentrations fit very well to a logarithmic relationship; in contrast, as illustrated for CD44hiCD8+ T cells, when the response between 0 and 5 µg IL-15 is used to define a linear slope the fit is very poor. Hence, the observed PD effects of single varying doses of IL-15 are not correlated with Cmax, but rather with the time receptors are occupied with sufficient IL-15 to expand immune cells.
We likewise inquired whether the high immune cell expansion after five daily doses of 5 µg IL-15 occurred abruptly during the study period, or increased steadily with repeated doses. Mice were administered doses of 5 µg IL-15 for 1–5 successive days (online supplemental figure S11). Here, the AUC28 d of proliferating NK and CD44hiCD8+ T cells were linear (R2=0.93) with the frequency of doses (figure 6B), as expected if each dose increased the time of exposure over some adequate target concentration. Taken together, the results indicate that optimal time-over-target cannot be achieved by single doses of different IL-15 quantities but can by multiple sequential doses of IL-15 or by a single administration of the long-acting MS~IL-1550 µg.
We also examined the PD effects of the super-agonist RLI, a single chain fusion of IL-15, and the 77 aa IL-15Rα sushi connected by a 20-amino acid linker. As an IL-15Rα-independent agonist, RLI binds with ~100-fold higher affinity to the intermediate affinity IL-2Rβ/γc than IL-1522 34 and has ~6-fold longer t1/2 in mice (table 1).35 As shown in figure 6A, 10 µg of RLI—equimolar to 6 µg IL-15—produces a PD effect >25 µg IL-15, and two doses of only 2 µg RLI separated by 2 days produces expansions superior to 10 µg of RLI or 50 µg IL-15. As with IL-15, the duration of receptor occupancy by RLI appears to play a more important role than dose intensity.
MS~IL-15 with an alternative linker and in vivo release rate
In early experiments, we also prepared and partially characterized an MS~IL-15 with the same MeSO2 modulator as in MS~IL-15 placed on a gem-dimethyl substituted linker36 designated MSGDM~IL-15. The in vitro release t1/2 extrapolated to pH 7.4, 37°C was 1000 hours, close to that of MS~IL-15. However, in C57BL/6J mice the t1/2 of released IL-15AP was 50 hours—still longer than any reported IL-15 agonist—but showed no second phase of CL. As calculated above for MS~IL-1550 μg, we estimated the IL-15AP released from MSGDM~IL-1550 μg over day 5 to be an average of ~8 µg/day. When MSGDM~IL-1550 μg was injected in mice, analysis of duration and AUC28 d of immune cell expansion was very similar, if not identical, to MS~IL-1550 μg (online supplemental figure S12 and table S2); thus, it appears that a t1/2 of 50 hr provides sufficient exposure to achieve optimal PD effects. Regardless, the present work focused on studies of MS~IL-15 because the longer t1/2 of released IL-15AP over 5 days more resembled that of the target 5-day CIV of IL-15.
Tolerability and safety of MS~IL-15
Toxicity and injection site reactions of subcutaneously administered MSGDM~IL-15 were assessed in mice. A complete summary of the study is provided in SI. Briefly, male C57BL/6J mice (n=6/group) were administered 0.1 mL of blank MS, MSGDM~IL-15150 μg, or MSGDM~IL-15500 μg on days 1 and 15 via subcutaneous injections and animals were observed for 28 days. There were no IL-15-related clinical pathologies, organ weight abnormalities, macroscopic findings, bodyweight changes, or dose-dependent microscopic differences between MSGDM~IL-15150 μg and MSGDM~IL-15500 μg. Slight injection site swelling and minimal to moderate subcutaneous granulomatous inflammation was observed in all groups and there was a single occurrence of mild myofiber degeneration/regeneration with MSGDM~IL-15150 μg. Hence, MSGDM~IL-15 administered day 1 and day 15 containing 150 or 500 μg IL-15/animal/injection—releasing 6-fold to 20-fold more IL-15 than the standard single dose of MS~IL-1550 µg used in this study—was generally well tolerated by mice.
Effect of MS~IL-15 and agonistic anti-CD40 on the TRAMP-C2 prostatic cancer model
In a previous study, a combination of IL-15, systemically administered at 2.5 μg/mouse 5 days/week×2, and anti-CD40 showed high synergistic antitumor activity in the primarily CD8+ T cell-driven murine TRAMP-C2 prostatic cancer model.24 Figure 7 shows the effects of subcutaneously administered IL-15 (figure 7A) or MS~IL-1550 µg (figure 7B) and IT administered anti-CD40 agonist in a bilateral syngeneic murine TRAMP-C2 model (Chen et al 2021, submitted). Here, the right tumor in each animal was injected with anti-CD40, and animals received ten intraperitoneal doses of 2.5 μg IL-15 over 14 days or a single subcutaneous dose of MS~IL-1550 μg. The combination of MS~IL-1550 µg and anti-CD40 resulted in significant expansion in the absolute number of peripheral CD8+ T cells, CD44hiCD8+ T cells, and tumor-specific tetramer+CD8+ cells compared with either monotherapy (online supplemental figure S13). Growth of both tumors in mice injected with single agent anti-CD40, IL-15, or MS~IL-1550 μg showed modest tumor growth inhibition. However, growth of tumors in mice receiving both unilateral IT anti-CD40 and systemic IL-15 or MS~IL-1550 µg were suppressed for long periods. As shown in figure 7B, none of the mice in the single agent MS~IL-1550 µg or anti-CD40 groups survived, whereas 50% of the mice in the MS~IL-1550 µg/anti-CD40 combination group were alive at day 60, all being tumor free. Hence, the combination of systemic MS~IL-1550 μg and unilateral IT anti-CD40 produce a potent effect on the tumor injected with anti-CD40 as well as the non-injected tumor.
Effect of MS~IL-15 and anti-CCR4 (mogamulizumab) on the MET-1 murine model of ATL)
It has been reported that IL-15 caused a NK cell-driven prolongation of survival of MET-1 tumor-bearing mice and thereby increased efficacy of anticancer mAbs through ADCC.26 Since the CC-chemokine receptor CCR4 is expressed on the surface of leukemic cells in most ATL cases,37 the MET-1 ATL model in NOD/SCID mice that lack T and B cells25 was used to test MS~IL-15 in combination with anti-CCR4. After intraperitoneal injection of MET-1 cells when serum-soluble human IL-2Rα—a surrogate tumor marker38—reached 1000 pg/mL, mice were treated with a single dose of MS~IL-1550 µg, every week×4 anti-CCR4, or the combination of MS~IL-1550 µg with every week×4 anti-CCR4 (figure 8A). We confirmed the expression of CCR4 and CD25 on the MET-1 leukemia cells (figure 8B). Treatment with MS~IL-1550 µg markedly increased the NKp46 cells in blood compared with the phosphate-buffered saline and anti-CCR4 groups (figure 8C–E). At 100-day post-treatments, 50% of the mice receiving combination of MS~IL-1550 µg and anti-CCR4 survived, whereas all others expired (figure 8F). Hence, the combination of MS-IL-15 and anti-CCR4 was highly effective at prolonging the survival of mice-bearing MET-1 leukemia.
Since the discovery of IL-15 in 1994,39 40 extensive efforts have been expended toward its development as an immuno-oncology agent.2 3 Foremost in achieving this goal have been endeavors to control the effects of IL-15 on NK and CD8+ T cells, which link the cytokine to its therapeutic effects. More recently, the effects of IL-15 on ɣδ T cells have received much interest because of their dual effects on both innate and adaptive immune responses, and potential importance in cancer immunotherapy.41 42 Optimal immune cell expansion requires IL-15 exposure at a level above a threshold concentration for a protracted period—a critical time-over-target.10–12 Since lower concentrations or times are not optimally efficacious, and higher concentrations or times may contribute to toxicities, an appropriate balance of agonist level and duration of exposure is essential. A major impediment to the success of IL-15 as an immunotherapeutic is that it has a short in vivo half-life of only 2.5 hours in the human; the high dose of a single injection necessary to achieve sufficient sustained exposure is accompanied by a high Cmax and associated toxicities.13 Hence, extensive efforts have been directed toward developing long-acting IL-15 agonists that remain within a narrow therapeutic window for long periods and achieve an optimal time-over-target.
In one approach, IL-15 super-agonists have been developed that increase potency and extend t1/2 by incorporation of IL-15Rα and, in some cases, an Fc fragment—those in current clinical development include N-803, hetIL-15, and RLI.14 When administered intravenously to humans, these super-agonists have elimination t1/2s of ~1.5 to 7.5 hours, which are not significantly different than the 2.5 h t1/2 of intravenously administered IL-15. However, when administered subcutaneously, the effective t1/2s are modestly increased to 4–24 hours because of slow absorption from their injection sites.31 43 44 In addition to slow absorption, some of the larger super-agonists are also poorly absorbed resulting in very low and potentially problematic bioavailability. For example, subcutaneously administered N-803—a large IL-15Rα-Fc complex with IL-15 N72D—has only 3% bioavailability which indicates that 97% of the agonist is disposed of at the injection site; the high residual IL-15 activity may recruit immune cells that cause the injection site rashes commonly seen with this agonist.43 Although IL-15 has been attached to other long-lived Fc or IgG fragments, longer-acting agonists have not materialized.14 In another approach, high MW PEG has been attached to IL-15 to provide NKTR-255 which when administered intravenously to humans gave a t1/2 of ~24 hours45; this makes NKTR-255 one of the IL-15 agonist front-runners, but the t1/2 is far from what is often achievable by PEGylation. In an alternative tactic, IL-2 has been PEGylated—for example, bempegaldesleukin and THOR-707—to bias binding toward IL-2Rβ/γc such that the effects on immune cells mimic those of IL-1546; these agonists also have modest t1/2 values of ~12 hours. Finally, the most effective approach to maintain optimal levels of IL-15 over time has been to administer IL-15 via 5-day or 10-day CIV, which show remarkable increases of CD8+ T cells, NK cells, and CD56bright NK cells as well as impressive expansion of ɣδ T cells.15 16 However, CIV administration is a generally unacceptable and impractical mode of administration.
The primary objective of the present work was to develop a subcutaneously administered long-acting IL-15 that would, insofar as possible, mimic the PK of CIV and expand target immune cells levels over an extended period. We first prepared and characterized hydrogel MS covalently attached to the N-terminus of IL-15 by a β-eliminative linker that slowly releases the agonist. We then studied the PKs of subcutaneously administered MS~IL-15 as well as its effect on expansion of target NK and CD8+ T cells. Lastly, we demonstrated that a single dose of MS~IL-15 is extremely effective in immunotherapy of cancer in both NK and CD8+ T cell-driven murine tumor models. Thus, with MS~IL-15 we have developed a slow releasing depot of IL-15 which after a single subcutaneous injection causes an effective and persistent increase of NK and CD44hiCD8+ T cells and high activity as an immunotherapeutic agent.
To prepare MS~IL-15, we first attached an azido-linker-aldehyde to the N-terminus of IL-15 by reductive amination using a stoichiometry that favors mono-alkylation versus multi-alkylation. Then, we attached the azido-linker-IL-15 to cyclooctyne-activated MS by strain-promoted azide-alkyne cycloaddition. The IL-15 in the MS~IL-15 depots exceeded 95% purity and was stable under physiological and storage conditions for prolonged periods. On β-eliminative cleavage of the linker, IL-15AP is released from the MS~IL-15, which was equipotent to IL-15 in a cell-based IL-2Rβ/γc dimerization assay.
On subcutaneous administration of MS~IL-15 containing 50 µg of IL-15 (MS~IL-1550 µg) to mice, the released IL-15AP maintained the ~200 to 300 pM plasma concentration of IL-15 effective in CIV16 29 with a t1/2 of about 1 week for 5 days—far longer than any IL-15 agonist thus far reported.14 It was serendipitous that the 5-day duration of high exposure of the released agonist was a similar duration as that of the 5-day CIV we sought to emulate.15 Interestingly, after ~5 days there was an abrupt decrease in t1/2 to about ~30 hours, which was maintained for a several week period. The biphasic PKs were not observed in immune-deficient NSG mice and we did not detect anti-IL-15 antibodies that might increase CL. Similar time-dependent increases in CL observed with the super-agonist hetIL-1531 and CIV infusion of IL-1516 29 have been attributed to formation of a dynamic IL-15 sink that consumes the cytokine, and the present study supports this hypothesis.
Most reported studies of IL-15 in mice use a paucity of measurements over time to quantitate expansion of immune cells. We measured target immune cell expansion in spleen, lymph nodes, and PBMCs over a 28-day period which—although tedious—covers the complete duration of immune cell expansion observed with MS~IL-1550 µg. To quantify proliferation and expansion, we developed an approach that measures the duration and extent that cells remained over controls. Here, we quantified the AUC of cell expansion over the 28-day study period, which is analogous to that commonly used in pharmacology to measure drug exposure over time. This approach allowed us to quantitatively compare long duration PD effects elicited by MS~IL-15 that would be difficult to accomplish by conventional methods. We showed that AUC28 d correlated well among tissues examined, and that MS~IL-15 elicits very prolonged and very robust PD effects on its target immune cells. Hence, measurements of AUC28 d provides compelling benefits over other approaches for quantitation of immune cell expansion by long-acting IL-15 agonists.
A single dose of MS~IL-1550 µg resulted in protracted cell expansion of ~14 days for NK, CD8+, and ɣδ T cells, and a very long 28 days for CD44hiCD8+ T cells. Indeed, the duration and expansion of immune cells elicited by MS~IL-1550 µg far exceeded alternative dose-equivalent administrations of free IL-15. For example, the PD effects of MS~IL-1550 µg greatly surpassed those from a single dose of 25 µg IL-15—the estimated amount of IL-15AP released from MS~IL-1550 µg over 5 days—as well as 50 µg IL-15—the total amount of IL-15 present on MS~IL-1550 µg. Also, the average AUC28 d values of proliferation and expansion of immune cells by MS~IL-1550 µg exceeded those from five daily injections of 5 µg IL-15 by ~150%. Interestingly, MSGDM~IL-1550 µg with a monophasic t1/2 of 50 hr showed similar PD effects as the longer acting MS~IL-1550 µg and may represent the minimal exposure time of IL-15 to provide an optimal PD effect. Hence, compared with various dose-equivalent schedules of IL-15, MS~IL-15 conjugates provide remarkably long and intense PD effects.
We also determined AUC28 d of immune cell expansion after injections of varying amounts and frequencies of IL-15 and the super-agonist RLI. The AUC28 d of immune cell expansion after single doses of varying amounts of IL-15 did not increase linearly as expected if expansion was directly related to dose and Cmax. Rather, proliferation and expansion of NK and CD44hiCD8+ T cells increased logarithmically with dosage, indicating that increasing doses affected the time over which the cytokine remained at a concentration needed for receptor occupancy and activation. With the super-agonist RLI—which has a higher affinity for IL-2Rβ/γc receptor and longer t1/2 than IL-15—two doses of only 2 µg separated by 2 days—equimolar to only 1.2 µg IL-15×2—produced expansions superior to a single dose of 10 µg RLI or 50 µg IL-15. Finally, the dose-linear AUC28 d of immune cell expansion after sequential single doses of 5 µg IL-15 was also consistent with linearly increasing the time of exposure. Taken together, these data show that the PD effects of different doses of IL-15 are not directly correlated with Cmax, but rather with the time receptors are occupied with sufficient IL-15 to expand immune cells. Hence, the necessary time-over-target for optimal expansion cannot be achieved by single doses of IL-15 because of its short t1/2, but can by multiple sequential doses or by the slow, steady release of IL-15 from a single subcutaneous administration of long-acting MS~IL-1550 µg.
These results all support the view that optimal in vivo proliferation of immune cells requires IL-15 exposure at a level above some minimal threshold concentration for some minimal period of time. However, cytokine stimulation that is too sustained or too frequent may be detrimental to immune cell expansion or function,33 47 48 and the optimal in vivo exposure time or level is yet to be determined. For example, Elpek et al47 found that transient treatment of mice with potent IL-15/IL-15Rα complexes increased the number and effector functions of activated NK cells, whereas prolonged stimulation led to accumulation of mature NK cells with impaired function. Likewise, Frutoso et al33 reported NK cell hyporesponsiveness to IL-15 agonists in mice whereby a second dose administered as long as 50 days after the first resulted in a large attenuation in NK-cell proliferation. On a second treatment of mice with MS~IL-15 1 month after the first, we also observed NK cell hyporesponsiveness. However, there are substantial interspecies differences in NK cell subsets and cell surface receptors in mice and humans, so the IL-15-induced NK hyporesponsiveness in mice need not translate to humans.49 50 Indeed, in non-human primates and humans immune cell responsiveness and effector functions do not appear significantly impaired after multiple doses of N-803,43 51 RLI,44 52 NKTR-255,45 or by CIV IL-15,15 16 29 especially if a suitable rest interval is allowed between doses or treatment cycles. In view of the apparent species differences of NK cell hyporesponsiveness and exhaustion, we did not consider it necessary to resolve these issues in mice and did not pursue further studies of multiple doses of MS~IL-15.
Finally, MS~IL-15 was assessed as an immunotherapeutic agent in two murine tumor models. First, it was tested in combination with IT-administered agonistic anti-CD40 in a bilateral TRAMP-C2 model of prostatic cancer (Chen, submitted), primarily driven by cytotoxic CD8+ T cells.24 A single subcutaneous injection of MS~IL-1550 μg and IT CD40 agonist in one of the tumors showed modest growth inhibition when individually administered, but evoked robust antitumor activity in both tumors when administered as a combination. Second, in the MET-1 model of ATL,26 driven by NK cells, a single dose of MS~IL-1550 μg caused a very large expansion of NK cells. Single-agent MS~IL-1550 μg or anti-CCR4 provided modest increases in survival, but a combination of both significantly prolonged survival. Clearly, MS~IL-15 should be pursued as an immunotherapeutic agent in human cancers, especially in combination with other agents that may be synergistic with the cytokine.
In summary, the MS~IL-15 prodrug provides a very long-acting IL-15—longer than any known IL-15 agonist—and the PD effects are likewise longer lasting than any IL-15 agonist yet reported. The IL-15 released from the MS has a low Cmax and causes protracted high expansion of NK cells and ɣδ and CD44hiCD8+ T cells. MS~IL-15 shows robust anticancer activity in NK and cytotoxic CD8+ T cell-driven responses, especially when administered in combination with other immunotherapeutic agents. From our perspective, important future work entails studies of MS~IL-15 in non-human primates and then in human clinical trials. Also, further studies on the MS delivery system should address (a) determining the optimal t1/2 of IL-15 release from the depot—sufficient but not excessive to produce optimal PD effects, (b) investigating the effects of an MS prodrug of a more potent, longer-acting super-agonist, such as the IL-15Rα-independent agonist RLI, and (c) applying the technology to other cytokines that could benefit from half-life extension. Since the PKs of MS~IL-15 are largely due to the nature of the β-eliminative linker connecting IL-15 to the carrier, and the rate of release is species-independent, we are optimistic that results obtained here will translate from mouse to man.
Data availability statement
All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplementary information.
Patient consent for publication
Animal experiments performed at the NIH/NCI were approved by the NCI Animal Care and Use Committee and were performed in accordance with NCI Animal Care and Use Committee guidelines. All other animal handling and care was performed by MuriGenics (Vallejo, California) and Explora Biolabs (San Francisco, California) and conformed to IACUC recommendations.
The authors would like to dedicate this manuscript to Dr Thomas Waldmann. The authors would like to thank Drs Christopher Carreras, Hongruo Yun, Shaun Fontaine, Jeff Henise, Rocio Fernandez, and Guillermo Hails for technical assistance, Dr Bora Han for advising on the toxicology study, and Dr Gary Ashley for insightful discussions.
This web only file has been produced by the BMJ Publishing Group from an electronic file supplied by the author(s) and has not been edited for content.
TAW and DVS contributed equally.
WC, SPD and AD contributed equally.
Contributors Conceptualization: DVS, TAW. Investigation: JAH, WC, SPD, AD, JRM, RR. Supervision: DVS, TAW. Writing: DVS, TAW, JAH. WC, SPD, and AD contributed equally. Guarantor: DVS.
Funding Some flow cytometry data reported was collected at the UCSF Helen Diller Family Comprehensive Cancer Center Lab for Cell Analysis, which is supported by the National Cancer Institute of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number P30CA082103.
Disclaimer The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.
Competing interests JAH, RR, and DVS are employees and hold options or stock in ProLynx Inc. All other authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Supplemental material This content has been supplied by the author(s). It has not been vetted by BMJ Publishing Group Limited (BMJ) and may not have been peer-reviewed. Any opinions or recommendations discussed are solely those of the author(s) and are not endorsed by BMJ. BMJ disclaims all liability and responsibility arising from any reliance placed on the content. Where the content includes any translated material, BMJ does not warrant the accuracy and reliability of the translations (including but not limited to local regulations, clinical guidelines, terminology, drug names and drug dosages), and is not responsible for any error and/or omissions arising from translation and adaptation or otherwise.