Background A minority of patients with advanced non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) benefit from treatment with immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs). Ineffective effector function of activated T and NK cells may lead to reduced tumor cell death, even when these activated effector cells are released from their immune checkpoint brake. Hence, in this study we aimed to assess the association of baseline serum granzyme B, as well as germline variation of the GZMB gene, with clinical outcome to programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1) blockade.
Methods A total of 347 patients with stage IV NSCLC who started nivolumab treatment between June 2013 and June 2017 were prospectively included. Baseline serum and whole blood was available, allowing for protein quantification and targeted DNA sequencing. Clinical outcome was based on best overall response (BOR) according to Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors, V.1.1, progression-free survival (PFS), and overall survival (OS).
Results Patients with low serum levels of granzyme B had worse PFS (HR: 1.96; 95% CI: 1.12 to 3.43; p=0.018) and worse OS (HR: 2.08; 95% CI: 1.12 to 3.87; p=0.021) than patients with high baseline serum levels. To validate the findings, germline variation of GZMB rs8192917 was assessed. Patients with homozygous and heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 had worse BOR (OR: 1.60; 95% CI: 1.01 to 2.52; p=0.044) and worse PFS (HR: 1.38; 95% CI:1.02 to 1.87; p=0.036) than wild types.
Conclusions A low baseline serum level of granzyme B and germline variation of GZMB was associated with worse clinical outcome in NSCLC, emphasizing the relevance and additional value of monitoring germline genetic variations which mirror cytotoxic functions of T cells in ICI therapy.
Trail registration number Dutch Trial Registry (NL6828).
- programmed cell death 1 receptor
- lung neoplasms
- genetic markers
- translational medical research
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
- programmed cell death 1 receptor
- lung neoplasms
- genetic markers
- translational medical research
Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) target immune effector cells, predominantly T cells, which may lead to an effective immune response toward tumor cells.1 2 Although ICIs have shown to significantly improve overall survival (OS) in advanced non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC), only a minority of patients benefit from treatment, with an objective response in about one out of five patients.3 4
The molecular mechanisms underlying resistance to ICI therapy are only partly explained. It is postulated that a combination of factors contribute to response, involving tumor biology, tumor microenvironment, the peripheral immune system, as well as germline genetics.5 6 programmed cell death protein 1 (PD-1)-mediated inhibition targets signaling downstream of the T cell receptor via its downstream phosphatase SHP-2, as well as costimulatory molecules.7 8 Importantly, distorted effector function of activated T and NK cells may lead to reduced tumor cell death, even when these activated effector cells are released from their PD-1 brake.
Previously, it has been demonstrated that immunohistochemical staining and in vivo imaging, using positron emission tomography, of intratumoral granzyme B may serve as a predictive biomarker for PD-1 blockade in melanoma.9 Granzyme B is a key serine protease that is secreted to induce apoptosis, primarily by activated T cells and NK cells.10 Distortion of granzyme B activity could be linked to reduced entry, trafficking, and accumulation within the cytoplasm of target cells (eg, tumor cells), and/or linked to reduced enzymatic activity, and hence decreased cleavage of intracellular substrates, such as caspase-3.11–13
Taken together, we hypothesize that low baseline serum levels of granzyme B, and consequently alterations of the GZMB locus, may contribute to resistance mechanisms of PD-1 blockade. The primary objectives of the current analysis were to assess the association of baseline serum granzyme B levels with progression-free survival (PFS) and OS after PD-1 blockade in patients with NSCLC. As a validation, genetic variants of the GZMB gene were related with PFS, OS and best overall response (BOR). Secondary objectives were to assess the relationship between serum granzyme B as well as genetic variations of GZMB and cytotoxic immune cell populations in blood.
Study design and data collection
Patients with advanced NSCLC who were treated with PD-1 ICIs between June 2013 and June 2017 at the Erasmus University MC (Rotterdam, The Netherlands) and the Amphia Hospital (Breda, The Netherlands) were prospectively included. Patients with NSCLC stage IV who had been treated with nivolumab monotherapy (3 mg/kg intravenous, once every 2 weeks) were included, and patients who were treated with a prior line of immunotherapy were excluded from the study. The study was approved by the independent ethics committee board (MEC 02-1002 and MEC 16-011) and all patients provided written informed consent. Whole blood and baseline serum were available for DNA analysis and protein quantification, respectively. All assays were performed blinded to study endpoints; patients were assigned to a subject number. Patient characteristics included demographic and clinical data. BOR was assessed according to the Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors V.1.1 (RECIST V.1.1).14 A minimum duration of 90 days for stable disease (SD) was required. Confirmation of partial response (PR) or complete response (CR) was not required. After treatment initiation, radiological evaluation by CT was usually performed every 6 weeks. PFS was defined as the time from the first administration of nivolumab until progressive disease (PD), or death due to any cause, whichever occurred first. OS was defined as the time from the first administration of nivolumab until death due to any cause.
Quantitative protein measurement and DNA analysis
Quantitative analysis of granzyme B in serum was performed by a magnetic bead-based assay, using a 1×96-well microplate and magnetic antigranzyme-B-coated beads (Human Magnetic Luminex Assay, R&D Systems Inc, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA). GZMB c.128T>C (rs8192917) was selected primarily based on its presumed contribution to resistance mechanisms of ICIs.9 A total of 12 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were selected in eight genes based on their contribution to T cell immunity and their correlation with overt T cell responses, such as the autoimmune diseases systemic lupus erythematosus and rheumatoid arthritis.15 ,16–25 A summary of the correlation of selected SNPs with overt T cell responses is displayed in online supplementary table 1. SNPs with a minor allele frequency (MAF) of <5% were excluded from the analysis. Linkage disequilibrium was tested using the application LDmatrix of LDlink V.5 (https://ldlink.nci.nih.gov/). Distribution of genotypes was tested for Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium (HWE) using the χ2 test. Deviations from HWE may reflect genotyping errors, though, may also be a signal of disease association,26 for example, mutation of tumor suppressor genes. DNA isolation and genotyping for GZMB rs8192917, HLA-A rs60131261, IL10 rs3024493, IL2RA rs3024493, IFNG rs2430561/rs2069705/rs2069718, PDCD1 rs2227981/rs10204525/rs2227982, PTPN11 rs2301756 and ZAP70 rs13420683 has been performed using TaqMan analysis as previously described.27 Whole-blood specimens were used for extraction of DNA. Genotyping was performed using predesigned TaqMan allelic discrimination assays, consisting of two allele-specific minor groove-binding probes. PCRs were performed in a reaction volume containing DNA, primers, and the specific probes were labeled with fluorescent dye.
Peripheral blood samples were analyzed using multiplex flow cytometry as previously described by Kunert et al.6 In short, absolute cell counts of immune cell populations were determined on whole blood after lysis of red blood cells, and frequencies of particular subsets were determined in more detail on cryopreserved peripheral blood mononuclear cell samples that were stained with a mix of antibodies.
Mutational burden and expression of PD-L1 in tumor tissue
Expression of programmed death-ligand 1 (PD-L1) and tumor mutational burden (TMB) have previously been determined in a subset of patients of cohort 1 (n=26; patients with stage IV NSCLC) using archival formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue samples.28 Baseline expression of PD-L1 has been determined using antibody clone SP263 (Roche Diagnostics, Tucson, Arizona, USA), whereas TMB has been measured using the Oncomine TML assay (Thermofisher Scientific, Waltham, Massachusetts, USA).
To study the relationship between baseline protein levels or SNPs and survival (PFS and OS), Cox regression analysis was used. Patient survival was visualized by the Kaplan-Meier approach. Patients were dichotomized for low or high granzyme B serum levels based on the median value of all patients. Dominant, recessive, and additive models29 were used to test associations between SNPs and clinical outcomes including BOR, PFS, and OS. HRs and 95% CIs were calculated. For the association of SNPs with radiological response, BOR was used as an ordered categorical variable with three levels, namely CR/PR (pooled), SD, and PD, by means of ordinal logistic regression analysis. This method assumes that the relationship between each pair of outcome groups is the same. The proportional odds assumption was checked for all analyses. Univariate ordinal logistic regression was applied for both SNPs and patient factors, and OR and 95% CIs were calculated. Multivariable ordinal logistic analysis was performed including both single SNPs and patient factors, with p<0.1 according to the univariate analyses. All analyses, with a significant relation (p<0.05) between SNP and clinical outcome, were internally validated by bootstrapping,30 where 1000 bootstrap samples were generated (with replacement) and 95% CIs were calculated for either ORs or HRs. Furthermore, bias and bias-corrected 95% CIs were calculated. In general, a p value <0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. Analyses were performed using IBM SPSS Statistics V.18.104.22.168 (Chicago, Illinois, USA) and STATA V.15.1 (StataCorp LP, College Station, Texas, USA).
Baseline serum from a total of 78 (cohort 1) and DNA from a total of 322 patients with stage IV NSCLC (cohort 2) was available for analysis (table 1). There was a 16.5% subject overlap between the patient cohorts. All patients were treated with at least one dose of nivolumab at 3 mg/kg once every 2 weeks. Overall, median absolute starting dose was 222 mg (IQR 192–263 mg). The objective response rate was similar in cohort 1 and cohort 2, respectively 19.2% and 16.6%. A minority (7%) of all patients could not be evaluated for response by RECIST V.1.1 due to early death, loss to follow-up or incomplete or absent follow-up tumor assessments. In the univariate analysis of cohort 2, WHO performance status (0 vs ≥1) and sex (male vs female) were significantly associated with PFS (HR: 0.66; 95% CI: 0.46 to 0.95; p=0.027 and HR: 1.38; 95% CI: 1.06 to 1.80; p=0.18, respectively) and OS (HR: 0.52; 95% CI: 0.34 to 0.77; p=0.001 and HR: 1.40; 95% CI: 1.05 to 1.86; p=0.023, respectively). In the multivariable analysis, only WHO performance status and primary tumor type remained significant for their association with, respectively PFS or OS and BOR.
Serum levels of granzyme B are associated with clinical outcome
Serum levels of granzyme B were determined in cohort 1 (online supplementary figure 1), having a median concentration of 1.27 pg/mL, which was used as the cut-off to dichotomize patients with low and high levels of serum granzyme B (as described in the Method section). Patients with low baseline serum levels of granzyme B had a significant worse PFS (HR: 1.96; 95% CI: 1.12 to 3.43; p=0.018, figure 1A) than patients with high levels of baseline serum granzyme B. Likewise, low levels of granzyme B were significantly associated with worse OS (HR: 2.08; 95% CI: 1.12 to 3.87; p=0.021, figure 1B) compared with high levels of granzyme B.
Germline variation of GZMB is associated with clinical outcome
To validate the findings in a second cohort by a different approach,31 genetic alterations of GZMB c.128T>C (rs8192917), together with a mechanism-of-action-based panel of other SNPs, were related to PFS, OS and BOR in cohort 2. Investigated SNPs with the corresponding haplotype frequencies, MAF and HWE statistics are shown in online supplementary table 2. After correction for WHO performance status and sex in multivariable analysis, patients with homozygous and heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 had worse PFS (HR: 1.38; 95% CI: 1.02 to 1.87; p=0.036; table 2, figure 1C). This finding could be internally validated (HR 95% CI: 1.02 to 1.87; bias: 0.003; bias-corrected 95% CI: 1.03 to 1.88; p=0.036; online supplementary table 3). Remaining SNPs were not associated with PFS after correction for patient factors (table 3). No significant association of SNPs with OS was observed after correction of patient factors (table 3). Of note, homozygous and heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 were not significantly associated with OS (HR: 1.19; 95% CI: 0.91 to 1.57; p=0.212; table 2, figure 1D). Homozygous and heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 were significantly associated with worse BOR (OR: 1.60; 95% CI: 1.01 to 2.52; p=0.044; table 2) and could be internally validated for the association with BOR (OR 95% CI: 1.05 to 2.55, bias: 0.007; bias-corrected 95% CI: 1.09 to 2.57; p=0.030, online supplementary table 3). All the results from both univariate (p<0.1) and multivariate analyses of the association with PFS, OS or BOR are shown in table 3. Results from the internal validation of factors that were significantly associated after correction for patient factors (p value <0.05) are shown in online supplementary table 3. For a subset of patients, both serum levels of granzyme B and germline variation of GZMB c.128T>C (rs8192917) were available for analysis. Patients with homozygous and heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 (n=19) had significant lower serum levels of granzyme B compared with patients with wild-type GZMB (n=34; mean difference 8.6 pg/mL, 95% CI 1.77 to 15.38, p=0.015).
Serum levels of granzyme B are accompanied by presence of T cells with terminal differentiation and exhausted phenotype
Next, we assessed the relationship between serum granzyme B as well as genetic variations of GZMB and cytotoxic immune cell populations in blood. Overall, there was a tendency that patients with lower serum granzyme B levels had lower absolute numbers of peripheral CD56+ NK cells (mean 141 vs 205 cells/µL, p=0.16; online supplementary figure 2) and CD8+ T cells (346 vs 463 cells/µL, p=0.41; figure 2A) when compared with patients with higher serum granzyme B levels. In fact, patients with homozygous or heterozygous variants of GZMB rs8192917 had a higher number of CD8+ T cells but not CD56+ NK cells than patients with wild-type GZMB (figure 2B and online supplementary figure 2B). Further, we studied whether granzyme B levels or GZMB genotypes correlate with frequencies of those immune cell phenotypes that correspond to either terminal differentiation (CCR7-CD45RA+) or exhaustion (PD1+ and TIM3+) of CD8+ T cells, as signs of T cell cytotoxicity. Interestingly, patients with lower serum granzyme B levels had a lower proportion of CCR7−CD45RA+CD8+ T cells (mean 44 vs 54 %, p=0.040) as well as PD1+TIM3+CD8+ T cells (mean 4.5 vs 7.8 %, p=0.001; figure 2A). No significant association nor trend could be observed between GZMB genotype and frequencies of T cells with these phenotypes (figure 2B).
Relationship between serum granzyme B, expression of PD-L1 and TMB
Interaction analysis for PFS and OS was performed between serum granzyme B, and PD-L1 and TMB in a subset of evaluable patients. In the univariate analysis, TMB (HR: 7.31; 95% CI: 1.5 to 34.7; p=0.01) was significantly correlated with PFS, while expression of PD-L1 (HR: 4.30; 95% CI: 0.9 to 19.8; p=0.06) or serum granzyme B (HR: 2.34; 95% CI: 0.9 to 5.9; p=0.07) did not meet the threshold for significance (online supplementary table 4). Moreover, only serum granzyme B was significantly correlated with OS (HR: 2.95; 95% CI: 1.09 to 7.93; p=0.03; online supplementary table 5). Multivariate analysis of these biomarkers (namely, serum granzyme B, PD-L1 and TMB) for PFS and OS did not meet significance. Of note, the HRs were in favor of higher levels of PD-L1 (≥50%), TMB (≥10 mut/Mb) and serum granzyme B (≥1.27 pg/mL), yet expression of PD-L1 (%), TMB (mut/Mb) and serum granzyme B levels (pg/mL) were not significantly correlated with each other (online supplementary table 6).
The present study demonstrates that serum levels of granzyme B and alterations of the GZMB locus may contribute to resistance mechanisms of PD-1 blockade. This concept (figure 3) is based on our findings that (1) low serum levels of granzyme B and (2) a common germline polymorphism of the GZMB gene were associated with worse clinical outcome after PD-1 blockade in patients with metastatic NSCLC. Moreover, serum levels of granzyme B were positively correlated with peripheral abundance of T cell populations that were highly differentiated or were expressing the immune checkpoints PD-1 and TIM3. The results are inline with our hypothesis that cytotoxic effector functions of lymphocytes (ie, through granzymes) are critical for the anti-PD-1 antibody-mediated immune effects.
Granzyme B levels were determined at baseline in patients with stage IV NSCLC prior to start with PD-1 ICIs. The median granzyme B level in this cohort was 1.27 pg/mL (range 0–88 pg/mL), which was lower than reported levels in healthy controls, for example, a median plasma granzyme B of 5.7 pg/mL (IQR 3.7–7.1 pg/mL; n=38)32 or 11.5 pg/mL (range 1–130 pg/mL; n=54).33 Measurements of granzyme B in serum were consistent with measurements in plasma.33 Our findings confirm the hypothesis that lower granzyme B levels in patients with metastatic cancer mirror the immune microenvironment of tumors favoring tumor growth by halting the antitumor response of cytotoxic immune cells. This may be a result of those germline variations that impact cytotoxic functions of lymphocytes.
Besides germline polymorphisms in the GZMB gene, polymorphisms in other genes have been investigated as well for their association with clinical outcome. Interestingly, these germline variations were not consistently found to correlate with PFS, OS, or BOR. Interpretations of these findings are challenging, and do not necessarily implicate an absence of effects of non-GZMB SNPs. Although SNPs were rationally selected by their correlations with autoimmunity (online supplementary table 2), we cannot exclude that SNPs in the investigated genes contribute to therapy resistance, as well as epigenetic or post-transcriptional regulation of gene expression or function. For example, PD-1 ICIs are suggested to only minimally target responses mediated by T cell receptors (involving ZAP70) and their primary method of action is most likely explained by relieving SHP-2 inhibition of the CD28 costimulatory pathway.8 Genomic alterations in tumors may involve loss of tumor antigens that are recognized by T cells, loss of antigen-presenting machinery components, tumor-induced inactivation of T cell signaling and insensitivity to effector functions of lymphocytes, death receptors or interferons.34
The nonsynonymous substitution of GZMB c.128T>C (rs8192917) was found to be in strong linkage disequilibrium with other common (MAF >15%) exonic variants, representing a haplotype block (data publicly available from The Single Nucleotide Polymorphism Database (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/snp/; online supplementary figure 3). This indicates that two predominant isoforms of granzyme B are expressed in the European population, defining two predominant isoforms, and is consistent with previous reports that genetic variation of GZMB leads to change of three amino acids of the mature protein (Q48P88Y245 to R48A88H245).15 35 Interestingly, the two isoforms have a similar expression, stability and proteolytic activity, however, the variant granzyme B isotype was observed to be incapable of inducing apoptosis in tumor cell lines in contrast to the functional effects of the more common isotype.36
Interaction analysis between granzyme B, expression of PD-L1 in tumor and TMB showed that these markers were not intercorrelated, which suggests their value as independent biomarkers for clinical outcome after PD-1 ICIs. Although our findings in regard to serum granzyme B and GZMB germline variation are confirmed in a large patient cohort and by internal validation, further investigations need to be performed to determine the clinical value as a predictive or prognostic biomarker of response to PD-1 blockade. These investigations include comparative analysis with these currently used biomarkers in an extended patient cohort, and evaluation of the diagnostic accuracy and mapping of the sensitivity of serum granzyme B in a prospective clinical trial. The results may not be directly applicable to other ethnic groups, as the study was performed in a European population.
An important aspect of our results is that germline genetics related to cytotoxic effector functions of lymphocytes contribute to mechanisms of resistance to ICI therapy. Previously, it has been shown that germline variations in regard to the antigen presentation machinery are related to response to ICIs, that is HLA-1 heterozygosity.37 Considering the urgent need to understand how genetic variation affects response to ICIs, as reviewed by Havel et al ,5 further work is warranted to identify novel genetic loci. We believe that apart from genes that are involved in antigen presentation, other immune-modulating genes may also contribute to response and resistance mechanisms of ICIs, of which granzyme B is an example. Determination of germline variations of patients with cancer contributing to response to ICIs may well be performed by future genome-wide association studies.
While the immune-oncology field rapidly advances, our understanding of ICI resistance mechanisms is limited and effective patient selection is lacking. Our data demonstrate that granzyme B is an important player in the antitumor immunity, as a consequence of the finding that low serum levels of granzyme B and germline variation of the GZMB gene contributes to resistance to PD-1 blockade in advanced NSCLC. As recent clinical trial results underline effective biomarker-based patient selection, future trials that incorporate granzyme B into diagnostics are considered as a promising step in this direction.
We thank Kazem Nasserinejad (Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The Netherlands) for his assistance with the statistics, and Wim Dik (Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The Netherlands) for performing the LUMINEX assay.
Contributors DPH, SB, AAMvdV, RHNvS, JA and RHJM contributed to the conception and design of the study. DPH drafted the manuscript. EO-DH contributed to the acquisition, analysis of data, and contributed statistical review of data. DPH, SLWK, AAMvdV, RD, RHNvS, JA and RHJM took part in interpretation of data. DPH, NS, AAMvdV and JA performed radiological evaluation. DPH and RD performed additional analysis of peripheral immune cell phenotypes. EB, NS and SEB contributed logistic, technical and material support. All authors contributed to critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Funding This research was funded by the Departments of Medical Oncology, Pulmonology, and Clinical Chemistry, Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Competing interests CHvdL reports non-financial support from BMS, MSD, Roche, Boehringer Ingelheim and AstraZeneca outside the submitted work. AAMvdV reports support from BMS, MSD, Sanofi, Roche, Novartis, Pfizer, Pierre Fabre, Ipsen, Eisai and Bayer outside the submitted work. JA reports personal fees from MSD, BMS, Amphera, Eli-Lilly, Takeda, Bayer, Roche, Boehringer Ingelheim, AstraZeneca outside the submitted work, and has a patent allogenic tumor cell lysate licensed to Amphera, a patent combination immunotherapy in cancer and a patent biomarker for immunotherapy pending. RHJM reports grants and non-financial support from Astellas, Bayer and Boehringer Ingelheim, grants from Cristal Therapeutics and Pamgene, grants and personal fees from Novartis, Servier, grants and non-financial support from Pfizer, grants from Roche, Sanofi, outside the submitted work.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
Ethics approval Ethics approval of Multomab study (Medical Ethical Board Erasmus MC ref. 16-011), patient signed written informed consent provided before study entry.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data availability statement Data are available upon reasonable request. The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.