Background Previous studies have reported that the amplification of some genes, such as Murine Double Minute 2 or 4 and Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor (EGFR), may be related to hyperprogressive disease (HPD). Exploring somatic gene alterations might be an effective method to predict HPD. Herein we characterize the somatic alterations in a patient with esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) who developed HPD to investigate the potential origins of HPD.
Case presentation A man in his mid-40s was diagnosed with ESCC. After the failure of first-line treatment with cisplatin and docetaxel, the patient participated in a phase III randomized, open, multicenter clinical trial (CTR20170307) and subsequently received camrelizumab. After 4 weeks of immunotherapy, the tumor size increased by 79% compared with baseline imaging; the progressive pace was 2.5-fold higher than preimmunotherapy, and a new liver metastasis appeared. A rare EGFR exon 2–28 duplication was discovered in both preimmunotherapy and postimmunotherapy tumor tissues.
Conclusion This is the first report on a patient with ESCC harboring rare EGFR kinase domain duplication in exons 2–28 and developing HPD in the process of camrelizumab treatment. This case suggested that EGFR kinase domain duplication might be associated with HPD. Administration of immune checkpoint inhibitor monotherapy in this subgroup of patients harboring EGFR kinase domain duplication should be performed with caution. These results need to be further confirmed in a larger cohort of patients.
- genetic markers
- tumor biomarkers
- antibodies, neoplasm
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to copy, redistribute, remix, transform and build upon this work for any purpose, provided the original work is properly cited, a link to the licence is given, and indication of whether changes were made. See https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs), including programmed cell death 1 (PD-1), programmed cell death ligand 1 (PD-L1) and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte-associated antigen (CTL)-4, have a positive effect on cancer treatment via reconstructing efficient antitumor T-cell response. Compared with traditional chemotherapy, ICIs, as a single agent or in combination, can bring a clear overall survival (OS) benefit, produce durable responses and have good tolerability in patients. Until now, a few ICIs, such as pembrolizumab and nivolumab, have been approved by the Food and Drug Administration in melanoma, non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC), colorectal cancer, gastric cancer and esophageal carcinoma (EC), and more drugs are awaiting to be approved. From this perspective, the future of ICI therapy seems to be bright.1 2 However, some recent studies have shown that ICIs do more harm than good since tumor growth acceleration occurs in a subset of patients, known as hyperprogressive disease (HPD).3–5 According to the work of Kato et al, HPD was defined as disease progression by RECIST V.1.1 criteria with a ≥2 fold increase in tumor growth rate compared with preimmunotherapy treatment, >50% increase in tumor load and time-to-treatment failure of <2 months during immunotherapy.6 A few studies suggested that the appearance of HPD was strongly associated with shorter OS and progression-free survival (PFS).7–9 Such HPD phenomenon was observed across many advanced cancers types, such as head and neck squamous cell carcinoma,10 NSCLC,7 urothelial carcinoma11 and gastrointestinal tract cancer.12 13 Considering the deleterious effects of HPD, we find it is important to find out patients who may develop HPD before ICI treatments.
Previous studies suggested that HPD was associated with many factors, such as advanced age,14 15 the number of metastatic sites15 or lactate dehydrogenase levels.15 However, the correlation between HPD and the aforementioned factors was still controversial.7 9 Additionally, several genomic alterations had been found to be correlated with HPD, such as murine double minute 2 or 4 (MDM2/MDM4) amplification,6 epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) amplification, the amplification of several genes on chromosomes 11q13-CCND1, FGF19, FGF3, and FGF4.16 Moreover, a few cases indicated that EGFR-mutated tumors (EGFR E746-A750 del and T790M mutation6 or EGFR exon 20 insertion mutation and MYC amplification17) also had a less satisfactory rate of response to ICIs and developed rapid progression. To sum up, the characterization of somatic gene alterations might be an effective method to predict HPD. Therefore, we characterized the somatic alterations in a patient with esophageal squamous cell carcinoma (ESCC) who developed HPD to investigate the potential origins of HPD.
A man in his mid-40s was diagnosed as ESCC. The patient underwent esophagectomy via thoracoabdominal approach without chemoradiotherapy, and his tumor node metastasis was pT1bN2M0. One year later, metastatic lesions were observed in the mediastina, the left axilla and the abdominal cavity. Then, he received first-line treatment with six cycles of cisplatin (60 mg, day 1; 40 mg days 2 and 3) plus docetaxel (140 mg, day 1).
After progression, the patient participated in a phase III randomized, open, multicenter study comparing camrelizumab (PD-1 blockade) to chemotherapy of physician's choice for patients with advanced EC (CTR20170307). During the clinical trial, he was assigned to receive camrelizumab (400 mg d1). After 4 weeks, the CT scans demonstrated a new liver metastasis and enlarged lymph nodes in the left axilla and abdominal cavity compared with baseline imaging (figure 1A). The tumor size increased by 79% compared with baseline imaging; the progressive pace was 2.5-fold higher than preimmunotherapy. (figure 1B). The progressive disease was evaluated as HPD according to the criteria defined by Kato and colleagues.6 The pathological analysis of new liver metastasis indicated ESCC. Additionally, squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) antigens, one of the tumor-associated antigens before and after immunotherapy were 9.6 and 24.4 ng/mL respectively (figure 1C). After the failure of anti-PD-1 therapy, three cycles of gemcitabine (1.8 g, days 1 and 5) and nedaplatin (70 mg, days 1 and 2) were administrated and then stopped because of pain. Subsequently, best supportive care was given afterward, yet the patient died of rapid systematic progression.
In order to investigate the mechanism of HPD, preimmunotherapy and postimmunotherapy tissues were subjected to next-generation sequencing in a College of American Pathologists-certified and Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendment-accredited laboratory, respectively.18 Before immunotherapy, the tumor mutation burden (TMB) of the tumor tissue was 3.23, and PD-L1 expression was observed in less than 1% of tumor cells (PD-L1 negative). The somatic alteration EGFR exon 2–28 duplication existed in both preimmunotherapy and postimmunotherapy tumor tissues (figure 2 and table 1), which suggested that it might be associated with HPD.
In this case, a man in his mid-40s was diagnosed as ESCC. After the failure of first-line chemotherapy, he participated in a phase III clinical trial and was assigned to receive camrelizumab. After 4 weeks of immunotherapy, the tumor size increased by 79% compared with baseline imaging; the progressive pace was 2.5-fold higher than preimmunotherapy; and a new liver metastasis appeared. The somatic alteration EGFR exon 2–28 duplication (existed in both preimmunotherapy and postimmunotherapy tumor tissues) was thought to be associated with HPD, which was never reported before. Reported HPD prediction factors include advanced age and more than two metastatic sites.7 14 However, sufficient evidence is not available. The current case had more than two metastases, but he was under 65 years old.
Considering that patients who developed HPD usually had worse OS and PFS compared with patients without HPD, an increasing attention has been paid on the relationship between somatic gene alterations and HPD during immunotherapy. MDM2/MDM4 is an important negative regulator of the tumor suppressor p53 by inhibiting its transcriptional activity and degrading it via ubiquitination. The MDM2/MDM4 amplification is significantly correlated with HPD. Kato et al provided a hypothesis that interferon (IFN)-γ elevated by ICIs in turn activates JAK-STAT signaling and interferon regulatory factor-8 expression, which can bind the promoter of gene MDM2 and result in the sequent hyperexpression of MDM2 in the patients harboring MDM2 amplification.6 Singavi and coworkers reported that one patient with ESCC harboring MDM4 amplification developed HPD during immunotherapy treatment.16 Besides, the amplification of EGFR and genes located on chromosome 11q13 (CCND1, FGF19, FGF3, and FGF4) might be also associated with HPD.16 In the present case, some gene amplifications, including CCND1, FGF19, FGF3, FGF4 and EGFR, existed in preimmunotherapy tissue, but such genes amplications disappeared in postimmunotherapy tissue, which suggests such genes may not be associated with the HPD of this patient.
Previous works demonstrated that the inactivated mutations of RB1 and TP53 usually occurred in the EGFR-mutant lung adenocarcinomas that transformed to small-cell lung cancer and other neuroendocrine carcinomas.19 Recently, TP53 mutation is associated with the significant clinical benefit to ICIs in NSCLC by cell signal pathways, such as cell cycle, DNA replication and damage repair.20Additionally, the comutation RB1 and TP53 existed in tumor immune microenvironment type I (high PD-L1/high CD8A) bladder tumors, which could significantly activate T-effector and IFN-γ signature.21 In view of the results mentioned earlier, the alterations of TP53 and RB1, which are also found in postimmunotherapy tissues, may not be suggested to contribute to ICI-related HPD.
In the case, the somatic alteration EGFR exon 2–28 duplication,subtype of EGFR-Kinase Domain Duplication(KDD), was associated with HPD. EGFR-KDD was first reported by Gallant et al in 2015.22 Such EGFR-KDDs are often observed in lung, brain and soft tissue cancers. The canonical EGFR-KDD is an in-frame tandem duplication of EGFR exons 18–25 (11/13). Besides, the unusual events, such as EGFR exons 17–25 duplication (1/13) and EGFR exons 14–26 duplication (1/13), are also reported.23 The EGFR exon 2–28 duplication is first reported in this case. Although EGFR-KDD has been known as one of the oncogenic drivers which can activate EGFR signaling via forming an intramolecular dimer, it has never been found in EC. Except EGFR-KDD, some tumors harboring other EGFR alterations, such as EGFR exon 20 insertion mutation, EGFR E746-A750 del and EGFR T790M mutation, also developed HPD during immunotherapy. A few studies are trying to explain the relationship between EGFR mutation and HPD. For example, previous study demonstrated that the EGFR activation could upregulate the expression of PD-1, PD-L1 and CTLA-1, promoting immune escape. In another study, it was found that anti-PD-1 agents could boost EGFR-mutant tumor growth through interaction with M2-like macrophages.24 This case reminded that administration of ICI monotherapy in this subgroup of patients harboring EGFR-KDD should be performed with caution in future clinical practice. Predictive biomarkers of response to immunotherapy, including positive factors (PD-L1 and TMB) and negative factors (EGFR and MDM2/MDM4 25), are needed before receiving immunotherapy.25 Ferrara et al suggested that addition of chemotherapy to ICIs was a potential method to overcome the PD-1/PD-L1 inhibitor resistance and ICI-related HPD.7 Such results need to be confirmed in further investigations.
In summary, the present case is the first report describing a patient with ESCC harboring EGFR-KDD who developed HPD during ICI treatment. In this case, EGFR exon 2–28 duplication was thought to be associated with HPD. Administration of ICI monotherapy should be performed with caution in this subgroup of patients harboring EGFR-KDD. The results should be confirmed in a larger cohort of patients, and the potential mechanism by which EGFR-KDD caused HPD during immunotherapy should also be investigated. Further analysis of such cases that developed HPD during ICI therapy might be helpful to find out putative predictive biomarkers for HPD.
The preimmunotherapy and postimmunotherapy tissue DNA alterations and TMB in a patient with ESCC who developed HPD were characterized via NGS 387 or 417 gene panel (3DMed, Shanghai, China).18 The PD-L1 expression was measured via SP142 and 22C3 immunohistochemistry assays, respectively.
We thank our patient and his family, colleagues at Shanghai Changhai Hospital and North Ruijin Hospital who supported us in the preparation of this paper, and 3D Medicines Inc. for support in next-generation sequencing. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Contributors M. Wang and W. Wang contributed to the planning, organization, data collection and writing of the manuscript, and analysis of the results. M. Liu performed the measurements. Z. Yan and G. Wang verified the analytical methods. D. Mao aided in interpreting the results and worked on the manuscript. M. Wang supervised the findings of this work. All authors discussed the results and contributed to the final manuscript.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent for publication Patient consent for publication is not applicable in this case since the patient died in June 2018.
Ethics approval This study was approved by the medical ethics committee of Ethics Shanghai Changhai Hospital,and informed consent was signed by the patient after approval by the ethics committee.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.