Table 3

Comparison of pathological outcomes

StudyPopulationPhNPETreatmentKey results
Neoadjuvant immunotherapy monotherapy vs dual immunotherapy
    CANOPY-N
    NCT03968419
Stage IB-IIIAII88MPRCanakinumab vs pembrolizumab vs combinedCanakinumab: MPR 2.9%
Pembrolizumab: MPR 11.1%
Combined: MPR 17.1%
    NeoCOAST
    NCT03794544
Stage I-IIIAII84MPRDurvalumab vs durvalumab+oleclumab vs durvalumab+monalizumab vs durvalumab+danvatirsenDurvalumab: MPR 11.1%
Oleclumab: MPR 19.0%
Monalizumab: MPR 30.0%
Danvatirsen: MPR 31.3%
    NEOSTAR
    NCT03158129
Stage I-IIIAII44MPRNivolumab vs nivolumab+ipilimumabNivolumab: MPR 22%
Nivo+ipilimumab: MPR 38%
Neoadjuvant chemotherapy vs chemoimmunotherapy
    TD-FOREKNOW
    NCT04338620
Stage IIIA-IIIBII88pCRCT+camrelizumab vs CTCT+camrelizumab: pCR 32.6%
CT: pCR 8.9%
    CheckMate 816
    NCT02998528
Stage IB-IIIAIII358EFS, pCRCT+nivolumab vs CTCT+nivolumab: pCR 24.0%, MPR 36.9%
CT: pCR 2.2%, MPR 8.9%
    NADIM II
    NCT03838159
Stage IIIA-IIIBII86pCRCT+nivolumab vs CTCT+nivolumab: pCR 37%
CT: pCR 7%
    AEGEAN
    NCT03800134
Stage II-IIIBIII740EFS, pCRCT+durvalumab vs CTDurvalumab: pCR 17.2%, MPR 33.3%
CT: pCR 4.3%, MPR 12.3%
    CheckMate 77T
    NCT04025879
Stage II-IIIBIII461EFSCT+nivolumab vs CTNivolumab: pCR 25.3%, MPR 35.4%
CT: pCR 4.7%, MPR 12.1%
    KEYNOTE-671
    NCT03425643
Stage II-IIIBIII797EFS, OSCT+pembrolizumab vs CTPembrolizumab: pCR 18.1%, MPR 30.2%
CT: pCR 4.0%, MPR 11.0%
    Neotorch
    NCT04158440
Stage II-IIIIII404EFS, MPRCT+toripalimab vs CTToripalimab: MPR 48.5%, pCR 24.8%
CT: MPR 8.4%, pCR 1.0%
    RATIONALE-315
    NCT04379635
Stage II-IIIAIII453EFS, MPRCT+tislelizumab vs
CT
Tislelizumab: MPR 56.2%, pCR 40.7%
CT: MPR 15.0%, pCR 5.7%
Neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy
    Albain et al
    PMID19632716
Stage IIIA(N2)III396OSCT/RT/S vs CT/RTpCR: 18%
    Epithor
    PMID37156211
T3-4 tumorsRS688OSS vs CT+S vs CT/RT/SCRT: pCR: 18.5%
CT: pCR: 6%
    ESPATUE
    PMID26527789
Stage IIIA-BIII246OSCT/RT/S vs CT/RTpCR 33%
    Cerfolio et al
    PMID19233668
Stage IIIRS216DESCT/RT/SpCR 33%
  • CT, chemotherapy; DES, descriptive endpoints; EFS, event-free survival; MPR, major pathological response; OS, overall survival; pCR, pathological complete response; PE, primary endpoints; Ph, phase; RS, retrospective study; RT, radiotherapy; S, surgery.